The Value and Meaning of Stripes

42559

Many academies have a system in place by which they promote between promotions.  This is done by putting a little tape “stripe” on the bar of the belt of the person being promoted.  Like belts, stripes can be relatively arbitrary, however stripes have an even deeper level arbitrariness (yes, that’s a word) as they do not have any bearing on competition.  Let’s take a look at why stripes exist, what their potential value is, and what their potential drawbacks are.

Stripes are an indication of a person’s progression through their belt rank.  One stripe is much further from the next belt than four stripes.  They give instructors a way to provide their students with tangible sort of feedback.  They also can serve as an indicator of how to roll with a person (a one stripe or no stripe guy may not be as good as someone with 3 or 4 stripes.)  Some schools require a certain number of stripes on a white belt in order to even roll.

Just to be clear: I think the stripe can be a very valuable coaching tool, and it definitely has its place in our world.  I won’t criticize the striping or belting process, but I am very interested in the broad terms with which we are often judged.  The way I see it is that the stripe doesn’t matter.  My stripe, your stripe, any individual’s specific stripe can mean a whole lot.  Like the belt.

What is the qualification for a stripe on a purple belt?  Is it the working understanding of 5 more moves than prior to the stripe?  6?  Is it 2 tournament wins?  There are no universal qualifications for it therefore it is arbitrary.

I’ve seen some of the very best competitors not get stripes added to their belts for a long time, and I’ve seen guys who practice casually get striped up quickly.  I’ve also trained at schools that don’t offer stripes at all, because they view it as a cheapening of the belt itself.

At the end of the day, stripes keep people interested.  Belts take a long time to earn in jiu jitsu and stripes are small victories that can keep practitioners who may not feel very confident in the game.  It can be frustrating to roll with higher level competitors who have more time to train than you.  The stripe is a reassurance that you are heading in the right direction.

I value stripes for that reason alone.  Personally I view stripes and belts as meaningful on the individual level but because of their arbitrary nature, how can we really attest to their significance?

How many stripes do you have on your belt?  Does every stripe feel like an achievement?  Or do you value the work put in to get that stripe over the stripe itself?

 

Previous articleRodolfo Vieira Vs Ben Henderson ADCC 2015 Open Weight
Next articleAwesome Jiu-Jitsu Match Between Boy Vs Girl
Emil Fischer is an active purple belt competitor under Pablo Angel Castro III training at Strong Style Mixed Martial Arts and Training Center near Cleveland Ohio (www.strongstyle.com). For more information, other articles, and competition videos check out his athlete pages at www.facebook.com/emilfischerbjj www.twitter.com/Emil_Fischer and https://instagram.com/emilfischerbjj/. Emil is sponsored by Pony Club Grappling Gear (www.ponyclubgrapplinggear.com), The Original Amy Joy Donuts (www.amyjoydonuts.com mention Emil Fischer when visiting), Valor Fightwear (http://valorfightwearusa.com/ discount code COOKIES), Impact Mouthguards (www.impactmouthguards.com discount code EMILIMPACT) and Gladiator Soap (www.gladiatorsoap.com discount code EMIL.FISCHER) as well as a brand ambassador for Ludwig Van (www.ludwigvantheman.com discount code FAMILY).

15 COMMENTS

  1. I agree belts and stripes mean nothing and everything at the same time. They mean nothing because anyone can wear anything without having any affect on actual skill level. However, being promoted is a rite of passage where you can officially claim to have a certain rank. At the very least, the stripes can help encourage a practitioner who might be on the fence about continuing to train, and if stripes encourage them to persevere, then it was worth the small piece of tape. On the other end of the spectrum, if you have practitioners who are more concerned with counting stripes and comparing belt colors, rather than improving their technique, then this would detrimental to the art and their jiu jitsu journeys. Great topic!

  2. Stripes or a psychological gift to the student. Yes it represents progress but its more for the student than anything else. Imagine being a Blue belt for 4 years with no stripes, not knowing when you will get your purple belt. Now imagine being a Blue belt for 4 years and having 4 stripes on you bar. Which one would make you feel better? I trained when stripes where only on Black belts. No 4th degree White Belts existed 😉 the stripes have become a tool or motivation and a business strategy, which is a win win situation for all. But that doesnt mean that a 2 stripe blue belt can’t kick a 4 stripe blue belts butt in the mat. Cause in actuality they are both still blue belts.

  3. I don’t see stripes as anything other than a way to measure your own progress.
    I may have 3 stripes on my blue belt but there are white belts at my gym who run rings around me…but unlike those white belts I’m a 43 year old woman who has 4 kids and started training 2 yrs ago. If my progress was measured and awarded against them, I’d have quit a long time ago. My stripes show me my coach can see improvement in my game.
    My BJJ journey is mine to make. I should be judged on that, not how well I do against an 18yr old male.

  4. My son is ten he is a yellow belt in class but a white belt in competition class when he gets strips it makes feel like he is doing good and that his instructor has noticed his progress, which in turn makes him wanna work harder and love bjj even more. That being said Keizer Oregon bjj is a reall good school.

  5. My instructor gives stripes for just ‘time served’ on the white belt, and a way to just give people who have been training a while a pat on the back. For later belts he doesn’t really bother all that much. Some people have gone straight from zero stripes up a belt.

    Personally, I’m not bothered. I trained a year without getting any stripes at all because he just forgot to give them out. In other martial arts I enjoyed the belt treadmill because there was a curriculum to learn and gradings to go to. In BJJ you get far more of a measure of how you’re progressing just by how you do in class every day, so who cares about stripes?

  6. At 46 and a purple belt I enjoy getting a piece of tape every now and then. But I am smart enough to know that in the grand scheme of things it really doesn’t mean that much. You have to be a purple belt to wear the purple belt. You won’t get promoted until you are ready no matter how many stripes you got.

  7. First it is great to hear from an older woman. Gen I applaud you. I am 73 started jujitsu 3 yrs agodoing woman self defence. I love the practice of awording stripes. I have 4 stripes on my white belt and am so proud of every one. I worked very hard for each stripe.

  8. I don’t train BJJ that long but as a 2 stripe white I am frequently tapping out some of the blue belts. Only yesterday our instructor was giving out stripes and awarded third one to a guy 120kg (white belt) I on the same day tapped with rear naked. Still, he is now technically better than me. In the bigger scheme of things I don’t really mind. Guys come down on the mat and train so they should be rewarded for it. Stripes or no stripes I’ll just do my thing and feel happy for whoever gets promoted. I just try to improve my game and make those who roll with me feel like they deserve what they earned. In the end of the day everyone gets caught at some point and one choke from someone with less stripes on his/her belt shouldn’t reflect overal skill or commitment for this sport.

  9. It’s funny that I just found this because I am currently in a situation where my instructor just gave me 3 stripes on Sunday. But I felt a little weird about it because in my heart I know I haven’t reached that level. I have only been training for about 3 months.
    I read an article on this website a few weeks back that explains how to deal with your instructor leveling you up when you don’t feel you’re ready. But the awkwardness about it, is when other white belts come in and have no stripes and start staring because they feel a bit slighted and then getting treated different as though I did something wrong.

    • Sometimes if you get 3 stripes on a white belt quick it’s normally because they are feelie rated at Judo/Wrestling or something similar. Not always the case just what I’ve seen ocassionally

  10. Been a purple belt 8 years, was a blue belt for 8 years before that, everyone I started before have passed me by and are are brown or black or gone. Been doing martial arts for 40 plus years, 15 black belts in other styles, stripe no stripe,you get what you put into it. I might be a purple belt ten more years or forever,doesn’t matter, If you love it , your path might be longer or quite short but it is yours to take.

  11. I received my first stripe and man this is the greatest feeling for me. I have been training with my instructor for private lessons for the past two years and some group classes in the summer. That white stripe motivated me to stay and learn more and more. I am 64 years old and I need rewards like this to keep me going. It was an honor to be in front of my fellow BJJ students getting this white stripe by instructor. I know that white stripe means the time I spent in class, the lessons I learned, and the rolling I did with fellow BJJ friends.

LEAVE A REPLY